Garage Door Repair or Replacement? How to Make the Right Call

James Edmonds avatar
James Edmonds
•
Cover for Garage Door Repair or Replacement? How to Make the Right Call

If your garage door has started sticking, groaning or dropping on one side, the first question is usually the same: is this worth fixing, or is it time for a new door? There is no single answer, but there is a sensible way to work it out. This guide covers the faults that are almost always worth repairing, the warning signs that a door is coming to the end of its life, and the questions to ask before you spend money either way.

We look after a lot of older up and over doors across Grantham, Newark, Sleaford and the villages in between, so much of what follows applies to them in particular. The same thinking works for roller, sectional and side hinged doors too.

Faults that are usually worth repairing

Most garage door problems come from the parts that move and wear, not from the door itself. If the door panel is sound, these jobs are normally a good use of money:

  • Broken or tired springs. Springs do the heavy lifting on most doors. On an up and over door they counterbalance the weight of the panel, and on a sectional door they wind up on a shaft above the opening. They fatigue over time and eventually snap. Replacing them brings the door back into balance so it is safe and easy to use.
  • Frayed or snapped cables. Cables on sectional and retractable doors carry a lot of load. A frayed cable should be replaced before it fails, because a door that drops on one side can jam in its tracks.
  • Worn rollers, pivots and bearings. Grinding, squealing and a jerky motion often come down to dry or worn running gear rather than anything serious.
  • Locks and handles. A lock that will not turn, or a handle that spins, is a straightforward fix. It is also a good moment to think about improving security.
  • Motor and control faults. Many electric door problems turn out to be a failed remote, a misaligned safety sensor or a control fault rather than a dead motor.
  • Worn seals. A perished bottom seal lets in rain, leaves and draughts, and replacing it is a small job.

Our garage door repairs service covers all of these on up and over, sectional and roller doors, including doors made by Garador, Hörmann, SWS, Henderson and Cardale. We assess the door and give you a clear quote before any work starts.

Signs a door is reaching the end of its life

Some problems are a sign that repairs will only buy a little time:

  • Rust through the panel or frame. Surface marks can be treated, but steel that has rusted through along the bottom edge or around the frame fixings is getting weaker every winter.
  • A bent or twisted panel. If a car has nudged the door, or the panel has been forced, it may never run true again however well the springs are set.
  • Rot in a timber door or frame. Timber can be repaired in places, but widespread rot usually means a new door and frame.
  • Parts that are hard to find. Older doors, particularly from ranges that have long been discontinued, can be difficult to get genuine parts for. Sometimes a universal part does the job well. Sometimes it does not.
  • Repeat breakdowns. One repair is normal wear. Several call outs in a short space of time usually point to a door that is worn throughout.
  • The door no longer suits how you use the garage. If you have to get out of the car in the rain to heave a heavy door open, or the garage is now a gym or workshop that is freezing all winter, a repair will not change that.

Questions to ask before you decide

How old is the door? A well made door that has been looked after can last 20 years or more. If yours is well past that and needs a major repair, it is worth getting a replacement price to compare against.

Is the panel itself sound? Springs, cables and locks can all be replaced. A damaged or rusted panel is the expensive part, and usually the point at which replacement makes more sense.

Will the repair fix the cause, or just the symptom? A new spring on a door with a twisted frame will wear out quickly. A good engineer will tell you if the fault you can see is a sign of something bigger.

What would a new door give you that this one cannot? Modern insulated doors keep an attached garage noticeably warmer, and current locking systems are a big step up from the single centre handle on many older up and over doors. If either matters to you, factor it in.

Could you upgrade instead? If you are happy with the door but tired of opening it by hand, many doors can be converted to electric operation without being replaced. Not every door is suitable, particularly some canopy up and over doors, so it is worth asking before you decide.

A note on safety

Garage door springs store a lot of energy. On an up and over door they are under tension, and on a sectional door the torsion springs are wound up tight. Adjusting or removing them without the right tools and training can cause serious injury, and a door with a broken spring or cable can move without warning. If you suspect either, stop using the door, keep children and pets clear, and call a professional.

If you decide to replace it

If the answer is a new door, our garage door types guide compares up and over, sectional, roller and side hinged doors, and the garage door costs guide explains what drives the price. Many people replacing an old up and over choose a modern up and over door because it fits the same opening with little disruption. Others take the chance to move to an insulated sectional or roller door.

We offer interest-free credit on garage doors, and you can see working doors from Hörmann, Garador, Ryterna and SWS at our Grantham showroom on Springfield Business Park. Our own team carries out every survey and installation. We do not subcontract.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it cheaper to repair or replace a garage door?

A single repair such as new springs, cables or a lock is almost always cheaper than a new door. Replacement starts to make sense when the panel or frame is damaged, parts are hard to find, or the door keeps breaking down. Ask for a repair quote and a replacement price at the same visit so you can compare them properly.

Can you repair an old up and over garage door?

Usually, yes. Springs, cables, pivots, locks and handles can be replaced on most up and over doors. The limiting factors are the condition of the panel and frame, and whether suitable parts are available for that particular door.

How long should a garage door last?

A good quality door that is installed properly and serviced should last 20 years or more. Electric operators tend to have a shorter life than the door itself. Regular servicing helps both last longer.

Do you repair garage doors that you did not fit?

Yes. We repair doors from all the major manufacturers, whoever installed them, and all our repair work comes with a year's warranty.

Not sure which way to go?

Tell us what your door is doing and we will give you an honest view on whether it is worth fixing. Get in touch or call us on 01476 833131.

If you want to know more about how GDCG can help your home improvement project get in touch using the details below:

Telephone: (0)1476 833131

Email: [email protected]

Guides

Customer Reviews

★★★★★
4.8/5
62 reviews
★★★★★
10/10
320 reviews

Trusted by hundreds of happy customers across Lincolnshire

Read All Customer Reviews →

Get Your Free Quote Today